What would happen to your business if one of the partners were to be absent tomorrow?

If you have a question about this topic, please Contact Us

7 lawyers Online Now

The continuity of a company does not depend solely on the business being profitable. It also depends on having made provisions for what will happen in the event of the death or incapacity of one of its partners.

In a Spanish SL, heirs may become shareholders, so the articles of association, valuation rules and funding arrangements should address an owner’s death before it occurs.

A profitable company can have loyal clients, healthy margins and years of growth behind it while remaining poorly prepared for the death of one of its owners.

The risk becomes particularly visible in companies owned 50/50. If one shareholder dies, their interest does not automatically pass to the surviving shareholder. In a Spanish limited liability company, or sociedad limitada (SL), the general rule under Article 110 of the Spanish Companies Act is that an heir or legatee who acquires the shares becomes a shareholder.

There is an alternative. The company’s articles of association can give the surviving shareholders, or failing them the company itself, a right to acquire the deceased owner’s shares at fair value.

A private shareholder agreement does not necessarily achieve the same result.

What happens to the shares when a shareholder dies?

In a Spanish SL, shares acquired through inheritance generally give the heir or legatee shareholder status unless a valid provision in the articles of association activates a permitted acquisition mechanism.

Transfer of shares on death (transmisión mortis causa de participaciones) is the transfer of an ownership interest in a company caused by the death of its holder.

Consider an SL valued at €1,000,000 and owned equally by two shareholders. Each 50% interest has a theoretical economic value of €500,000.

If one owner dies, the company is dealing with more than the loss of a person who may have been important to its operations. It also needs to establish who succeeds to the deceased owner’s interest and what Spanish company law says about those shares.

The heirs may know the business and wish to remain involved. They may have no interest in doing so.

That creates the problem.

The surviving shareholder might want to acquire the shares while the heirs prefer cash. Even then, the parties still need to establish the value and find the €500,000 required to complete the transaction.

Do the heirs automatically become shareholders of a Spanish SL?

As a general rule, yes. Article 110.1 of the Spanish Companies Act (Ley de Sociedades de Capital) states that an heir or legatee acquiring company shares through succession obtains shareholder status.

That can materially change a small company’s ownership structure.

A company that previously had two shareholders may suddenly have one side of its capital inherited by a spouse, several children or other beneficiaries. Where several people jointly own the same shares, Article 126 requires them to appoint one person to exercise the shareholder rights attached to those shares.

Ownership does not answer every management question either. Being a shareholder and being a company director are legally different roles.

Business succession planning (planificación de continuidad empresarial) therefore needs to separate ownership of the shares, voting rights and day-to-day management.

Can the surviving shareholders buy the deceased owner's shares?

Yes, but an SL wishing to use the specific mechanism in Article 110.2 needs an appropriate provision in its articles of association.

The articles may grant the surviving shareholders and, failing them, the company a right to acquire the deceased shareholder’s interest.

Spanish law attaches specific conditions. The shares are valued at their fair value on the date of death, the price must be paid in cash and the acquisition right must be exercised within a maximum of three months after the company is notified of the inherited acquisition.

This is very different from a vague understanding that “if one of us dies, the other will keep the company”.

In the €1,000,000 company example, a suitable provision may supply the legal mechanism for the surviving owner to acquire the deceased’s 50% interest. It does not supply the €500,000 purchase price.

There are therefore two separate questions: can the survivor buy, and can the survivor pay?

Is a shareholder agreement enough?

Not necessarily. A shareholder agreement (pacto de socios) and the company’s articles of association do not always have the same legal effect against the company.

A shareholder agreement is a contract in which shareholders regulate matters such as ownership, voting, transfers, governance, exits and particular events affecting their relationship.

Article 29 of the Spanish Companies Act states that agreements kept private between shareholders cannot be enforced against the company. The articles of association operate at company level and may include terms permitted by law and consistent with the principles governing the relevant company type.

A provision contained only in a private agreement should therefore not be assumed to produce the same corporate consequences as a correctly drafted article of association.

Spain also expressly recognises the family protocol (protocolo familiar). Royal Decree 171/2007 defines it for its purposes as a set of agreements governing relationships between family, ownership and the business in a non-listed company, and provides voluntary mechanisms for making such protocols or certain implementing provisions public through the Commercial Registry.

  • Shareholder agreement: regulates contractual commitments among its parties.
  • Articles of association: govern the company and can include permitted rules dealing with transfers on death.
  • Will: deals with succession under the applicable inheritance law but does not replace company law.
  • Insurance or financial reserves: can provide funding but do not create the right to acquire the shares.

They may support the same plan. They perform different legal functions.

How is the value of the shares established?

For the acquisition mechanism under Article 110, the statutory reference is the fair value of the shares on the date of death.

Valuation may become the main point of disagreement.

A company with assets worth €1,000,000 does not necessarily have equity worth €1,000,000. Debt, cash, recurring contracts, margins, intellectual property, property holdings and dependence on one founder can all affect economic value.

Article 353 of the Spanish Companies Act states that, where the parties cannot agree on fair value, the valuer or the valuation procedure, an independent expert appointed by the Commercial Registrar at the company’s registered office can determine the value at the request of the company or the shareholders holding the shares concerned.

This raises a useful question while both owners are alive: how would we value this company if one of us died tomorrow?

A pre-agreed methodology may reduce uncertainty, subject to the mandatory rules that apply to the specific transaction.

And valuations age. A figure agreed five years ago may bear little relationship to the current business.

Are the rules the same for an SL and an SA?

No. Spanish law treats shares in a sociedad limitada and shares in a sociedad anónima (SA) differently.

For an SA, restrictions in the articles of association on transfers following death apply only if the articles expressly say so.

Under Article 124 of the Spanish Companies Act, where such restrictions apply and the company refuses to register the inherited transfer of registered shares, it must present the heir with a buyer or offer to acquire the shares itself at fair value. The provision also establishes an independent valuation mechanism.

A continuity review should therefore start by confirming the legal form of the company and obtaining the current registered articles of association.

Rules written for an SL should not simply be copied into an SA strategy.

What if the shareholder is foreign or lives outside Spain?

An international shareholder requires succession law and Spanish company law to be considered separately and then coordinated.

Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 generally uses the deceased person’s habitual residence at death to determine the law governing the succession, while permitting a person in certain circumstances to choose the law of their nationality.

The Regulation expressly excludes matters governed by company law from its scope, including provisions in companies’ constitutional documents that determine what happens to company shares when a member dies.

This distinction matters for a British, German, Dutch, Scandinavian, US or Latin American entrepreneur holding shares in a Spanish company.

Succession law helps establish who inherits. Spanish company law and the SL’s articles determine what corporate consequences follow and whether a statutory acquisition mechanism applies.

Both need to be reviewed.

Can life insurance fund the purchase of the shares?

Yes. Life insurance may be considered as a source of liquidity, but it does not replace the legal mechanism required to transfer the company interest.

Return to the company worth €1,000,000. If the surviving shareholder expects to acquire a 50% interest worth approximately €500,000, access to capital can determine whether the transaction is realistically achievable.

Spain’s Insurance Contract Act, Law 50/1980, allows life insurance to be written on the policyholder’s life or the life of another person. For death cover where the policyholder and insured person are different, Article 83 requires the insured person’s written consent subject to the qualification contained in the provision concerning the policyholder’s interest in that person’s life.

Beneficiary designation matters too. Article 84 permits the policyholder to designate the beneficiary in the policy, through a later written communication to the insurer or by will.

Tax then has to be considered.

The Spanish Tax Agency states that where an individual receives life insurance proceeds and the policyholder is a different person, the proceeds may fall within Spanish Inheritance and Gift Tax. Increases in wealth received by legal entities are not subject to that tax, although other tax rules may apply.

The policyholder, insured person, beneficiary and intended use of the money therefore need to be identified before a policy is treated as the funding solution.

Insurance supplies cash. It does not replace the articles, shareholder agreement or succession documents.

Can the company build a financial reserve instead?

Yes. Building liquidity over time can reduce the amount that needs to be borrowed or insured when an ownership transition occurs.

The appropriate amount depends on the company’s operating requirements and its financial and tax position.

For a company worth €1,000,000, a potential €500,000 funding need does not necessarily have to be covered by one source. Available cash, accumulated reserves, borrowing, liquid investments and insurance may form different parts of the funding analysis where legally and financially appropriate.

There is an obvious trade-off. Money retained for a future contingency is money that cannot simultaneously be distributed or invested elsewhere.

There is no standard figure for every business.

The required liquidity depends on company value, ownership percentages, the shareholders’ circumstances, the planned acquisition structure and the amount of debt the business or surviving owners could reasonably support.

What should shareholders review now?

The starting point should be the legal documents already governing the company rather than an insurance product.

  1. Obtain the current registered articles of association from the Spanish Commercial Registry.
  2. Check what they say about transfers of shares following the death of a shareholder.
  3. Review any shareholder agreement or family protocol and establish which obligations it creates and against whom they can be enforced.
  4. Identify the succession law likely to apply to each shareholder and review their wills, particularly where owners have international connections.
  5. Decide the desired outcome: heirs entering the company, acquisition by surviving shareholders, acquisition by the company or another legally available structure.
  6. Establish a workable valuation approach and review it periodically as the company changes.
  7. Calculate the likely amount of liquidity needed to implement the plan.
  8. Compare possible funding sources, including existing cash, accumulated reserves, borrowing and appropriately structured life insurance.
  9. Coordinate the articles, shareholder agreement, succession arrangements and funding so that one document does not undermine another.

The objective is not to predict when a shareholder will die. It is to know what the legal process and funding position would be if it happened.

Does business succession planning also protect the family?

Yes. A defined exit mechanism may allow the deceased shareholder’s family to convert an inherited business interest into cash if they do not wish to participate in the company.

Inheriting 50% of a company valued at €1,000,000 is not the same as receiving €500,000 in a bank account.

The shares may have no immediate external buyer. Their value may be disputed. The heirs may find themselves owning a substantial interest in a business they do not understand and did not choose to join.

A properly coordinated structure can reduce that uncertainty by setting out a legally valid acquisition mechanism, a valuation process and a realistic source of funding.

It can protect the surviving shareholder too. The future of the company does not then have to be negotiated from scratch in the weeks following a partner’s death.

Frequently asked questions

They may become shareholders if they inherit the shares. Article 110 of the Spanish Companies Act provides that an heir or legatee acquiring shares through succession generally obtains shareholder status. The articles can establish an acquisition right for the surviving shareholders or, failing them, the company, subject to the statutory requirements.

A private shareholder agreement should not be treated as equivalent to the articles of association. Article 29 of the Spanish Companies Act states that agreements kept private between shareholders cannot be enforced against the company. If an SL wants to use the acquisition mechanism under Article 110.2, the relevant provision and its coordination with the articles require specific legal review.

Where an SL’s articles contain the acquisition right contemplated by Article 110.2, it must be exercised within a maximum of three months after the inherited acquisition is communicated to the company. The statutory mechanism uses the fair value of the shares on the date of death and requires the purchase price to be paid in cash.

Article 353 of the Spanish Companies Act provides an independent valuation mechanism where there is no agreement about fair value, the valuer or the valuation procedure. An independent expert may be appointed by the Commercial Registrar for the company’s registered office at the request of the company or the shareholders holding the relevant shares.

No. Insurance can provide money but does not itself transfer shares or compel the heirs to sell. The company law mechanism, articles of association, shareholder agreement, succession arrangements and insurance structure must work together. Tax treatment should also be reviewed according to the identity of the policyholder, insured person and beneficiary.

Succession and company law must be separated. Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 may determine the law governing an international shareholder’s succession, but it expressly excludes certain company-law matters, including constitutional provisions determining the fate of company shares on a member’s death. Both legal regimes therefore need to be considered.

A company prepared for the death of a shareholder knows who may inherit the shares, who can acquire them, how they will be valued and where the purchase money will come from.

Without those four answers, one death can change the ownership, control and financial position of the business at the same time.

Information search

If you have a friend or know someone who may be interested in this topic, you can share or send this text using these buttons:

Need more info? We are here to help